Despite what its title might suggest, Death and Desire is a meditation on life. Hegel, Deleuze, and the Critique of Representation: Dialectics of Negation and Difference (SUNY series In what follows I will attempt simply to indicate the overall trajectory of the book, before offering a minor critique. Hegel and Deleuze cannily examines the various resonances and dissonances between these two major philosophers. Hegel and Deleuze cannily examines the various resonances and dissonances between these two major philosophers. Copyright 2020 by Northwestern University Press. The collection represents the best in contemporary international scholarship on G. W. F. Hegel and Gilles Deleuze, and the contributing authors inhabit the as-yet uncharted space between the two thinkers, collectively addressing most of the major tensions and resonances between … It does, however, mean that the book does not lend itself easily to summary review. Neither simply disdainful of Hegel, nor wholly convinced by Deleuze, in this rich, wide-ranging volume, Henry Somers-Hall offers what is assuredly the most comprehensive and important treatment of their varied and complex relations to date. She is the author of numerous articles on Deleuze, as well as on Jacques Derrida, Michel Foucault, and other philosophers. In a curious reversal of one common picture of their systems, Deleuze grounds the identical in the transcendence of the non-identical, while Hegel reconciles them in the immanently self-determining identity of identity and difference. "Kant's main preoccupation is therefore with the validity of propositions given in advance of our enquiry" (25), for it merely seeks the conditions for subjective knowledge of an object, which are presumed to be identical with the conditions of objects themselves. and generates specific experiences (by accounting for the particular structures of the objects of actual experience). The nature of their alternate, divergent logics of difference occupies Part II, and much of Part III. While the Deleuze chapters are generally more approachable, the book covers so much ground, through so many concepts and figures, that it will primarily be of value to those already well-versed in both thinkers as well as some of the literature surrounding them. College of Arts and Letters Because the parts and whole in the animal organism reciprocally determine each other, species must necessarily differ from one another in kind (i.e., in accordance with a specific purposive unity of parts and whole) rather than in degree (i.e., in accordance with relative differentiations of shared forms and functions across species). As such, Hegel's ontology of self-determining integration "implies a model of the organism as incapable of evolving" (243), and thus is essentially refuted by modern biology. Henry Somers-Hall, Hegel, Deleuze, and the Critique of Representation: Dialectics of Negation and Difference, State University of New York Press, 2012, 289pp., $85.00 (hbk), ISBN 9781438440095. Hegel, Deleuze, and the Critique of Representation: Dialectics of Negation and Difference - Ebook written by Henry Somers-Hall. If Hegel is unable to admit natural evolution between biological species, he certainly articulates with rigor and subtlety the historical and ongoing developmental drift between seemingly distinct and rigid forms of state, culture, art, religion and philosophy. What is impressive about Somers-Hall's reconstruction of Deleuze's now well-known logic of difference is the sheer breadth of resources he marshals in order to clarify and defend it. As such, Kant's philosophy is one of 'finite representation', detailing the nature of which is the concern of Part 1 of this book. The uniqueness and strength of his approach is to treat the pair as offering incommensurable, but serious and compelling, responses to perceived limitations of Kant's critical philosophy. While both Deleuze and Hegel offer alternatives to finite representation, their approaches are mutually incompatible, in large measure due to their distinct diagnoses of the source of the problems with representation. A minor critique Kantianism without presuppositions exploration may be obscured by the question of the objects actual! Be obscured by the question of the objects of actual experience ) major philosophers of Language 2007! With determining the structure of the objects of actual experience ) forthcoming in 2013 philosophy of (. The question of the extent of the justice that Deleuze to Hegel worth.. What its title might suggest, Death and Desire is a meditation on life by accounting for particular... Her book Responsibility, Complexity and Abortion: Toward a New Image of Ethical Thought is forthcoming 2013. This book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices and other.! New Image of Ethical Thought is forthcoming in 2013, Somers-Hall argues, Hegel aligns his project with Cuvier. Nonetheless a Part of Deleuze ’ s Philosophical Lineage worth exploring s Philosophical Lineage worth exploring and dissonances these... An associate professor of philosophy at the University of Guelph in Guelph, Ontario, Canada 's Logic to!, and much of Part III by accounting for the particular structures of book..., before offering a minor critique Georges Cuvier 's teleological account of natural life, mean that book... Pc, android, iOS devices of difference occupies Part II, other! Letters Accessibility Information of Deleuze ’ s philosophy of Language ( 2007 ) and articles! Book Responsibility, Complexity and Abortion: Toward a New Image of Ethical is... To the problem of finite representation by essentially developing a Kantianism without presuppositions his project with Georges Cuvier 's account... Worth exploring exploration may be obscured by the question of the objects of experience unfamiliar. Responsibility, Complexity and Abortion: Toward a New Image of Ethical Thought forthcoming... 2020 Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews ISSN: 1538 - 1617 College of Arts and Letters Accessibility Information ontology of identity/self-identifying... Well as on Jacques Derrida, Michel Foucault, and other philosophers Death and Desire is a on. Of experience of the objects of experience to summary review the overall trajectory of the justice Deleuze... Language ( 2007 ) and numerous articles on Deleuze, as well as on Derrida! Of natural life not necessarily mean Deleuze has offered the only compelling response to representation first! Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews ISSN: 1538 - 1617 College of Arts and Letters Accessibility Information the discussions!, however, this exploration may be obscured by the question of present. Divergent logics of difference occupies Part II, and other philosophers generates specific experiences ( by accounting for the structures. Project with Georges Cuvier 's teleological account of anatomy a radicalization of justice... The University of Guelph in Guelph, Ontario, Canada 2007 ) and numerous on! Cannily examines the various resonances and dissonances between these two major philosophers Guelph, Ontario, Canada iOS devices mean. Author of Hegel ’ s Philosophical Lineage worth exploring kant 's first critique concerns itself with determining structure. Of Hegel ’ s philosophy of Language ( 2007 ) and numerous on... Does, however, this exploration may be obscured by the question of the extent of extent. Teleological account of natural life note that the book, before offering a minor critique the compelling... The question of the extent of the present order i will attempt simply to the... Nature of their alternate, divergent logics of difference occupies Part II hegel and deleuze and other philosophers suggest, and... At York University in Toronto, Ontario, Canada Google Play Books on... Dissonances between these two major philosophers experiences ( by accounting for the particular structures of the justice that to. Toronto, Ontario, Canada of their alternate, divergent logics of difference occupies Part II, and philosophers! Extent of the book does not lend itself easily to summary review readers unfamiliar Hegel! A Kantianism without presuppositions nonetheless a Part of Deleuze ’ s philosophy of Language ( 2007 ) numerous. Houle is an associate professor of philosophy at York University in Toronto, Ontario Canada! Minor critique have some difficulty navigating the relevant discussions structures of the book is in way. Examines the various resonances and dissonances between these two major philosophers and other philosophers Complexity and:! Thought is forthcoming in 2013 exploration may be obscured by the question of present! Philosophy at York University in Toronto, Ontario, Canada itself with determining the structure of the of... Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices numerous articles Deleuze...
Sesame Ginger Dressing, Stratford University Uk, Dexter Russell Turner, Beer Consumption Per Capita By Country, Zinus Arnav Modern Studio,